What happens to my second mortgage if the first mortgagee sells?

A second mortgage lives or dies by its place in the queue. When the lender in first place decides to sell, the junior lender doesn’t get a vote, and the borrower is often too busy panicking about the first mortgage to notice the second one is also at risk.

This guide sets out who is paid from a mortgagee sale and in what order, what a second mortgagee can and can’t do, and the points at which a borrower can still change the outcome.

Who gets paid first when the first mortgagee sells?

The money from the sale is paid out in a fixed queue, roughly like this:

1. Costs of the sale: agent’s commission, advertising, legal fees and the mortgagee’s enforcement expenses under its loan contract.
2. The first mortgage: principal, interest and the fees the contract allows.
3. Junior mortgages, in their registered order: the second mortgage, then a third if there is one.
4. The owner, who receives anything left.

State legislation backs this up. Queensland’s Property Law Act 1974 deals with the application of proceeds, including payment to subsequent mortgagees, and NSW and Victoria require a selling mortgagee to pay surplus to the holder of a subsequent mortgage, as law firm Lavan sets out in its note on surplus proceeds. Which section applies depends on the state the property is in, so your solicitor should confirm the exact provisions for your title.

The point most owners miss is the first item. Sale costs come off the top, so a forced sale can leave a smaller pool for the second mortgage than the headline price suggests. Our page on how second mortgages rank explains why that queue is fixed from the day the mortgages are registered.

What happens to the second mortgage on the title?

It comes off. When the mortgagee’s sale settles, the buyer takes the property free of the mortgagee’s mortgage and of the mortgages ranking behind it. A Victorian property law commentary describes the second mortgage being discharged automatically at settlement where nothing is left over for the junior lender, a result linked to section 77 of the Transfer of Land Act 1958.

Read that sentence again if you are the borrower. The security goes. The debt may not. If the proceeds paid the second lender only part of what it was owed, the shortfall is typically an unsecured claim against the borrower and any guarantors. Their personal liability is the real cost of a forced sale at a poor price.

Illustrative example: a property is sold by the bank for $1.2m. Sale costs take $60k and the bank loan is $900k, leaving $240k. The second mortgage is $300k. The second lender receives $240k, the title is cleared, and the borrower still owes the remaining $60k plus costs, now unsecured. Change the sale price by a few percent either way and the shortfall swings sharply, which is why the price the first mortgagee achieves matters to everyone behind it.

Does the second mortgagee get notice of the sale?

Don’t count on a courtesy call. Notice requirements depend on the state, the type of sale and the contract. A mortgagee may also be required to give notice to subsequent encumbrancers on the title in some situations, and some do so as a matter of practice before a private treaty sale. The safe approach is not to wait.

For the borrower, that means telling the second lender the day a default notice, a letter of demand or a sale appraisal from the first lender arrives. For the junior lender, it means watching the title and the loan, and acting at the first sign of arrears on the first mortgage. Lenders that find out only when contracts have exchanged have the fewest options.

Our guide on what happens if you can’t repay a private loan covers the default sequence on the second loan itself.

What can a second mortgagee do before the sale?

More than most people expect, but nearly all of it costs money and takes speed.

• Pay out the first mortgage. A subsequent mortgagee can usually discharge the prior mortgage in full and step into its shoes. Victoria’s Transfer of Land Act has a specific provision for this (section 128A, according to practitioner commentary). The junior lender then controls the timing and price of any sale.
• Ask the first mortgagee to hold off. Banks will sometimes pause if a credible refinance or a better-priced private sale is on the table.
• Ask about the price. Mortgagees owe a duty to take reasonable care to sell at market value, which is set out in section 85 of Queensland’s Property Law Act 1974 and section 111A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW). A very low result, or a rushed auction with thin marketing, can be challenged, and the junior lender’s complaint carries the most weight when it is raised before settlement, with the sale evidence in hand: the marketing period, the agent’s appraisal and any competing offers.
• Hold the surplus claim. If a surplus is likely, the second mortgagee’s claim is to the money, and it should be in writing early.

One more complication: other parties can claim ahead of a junior mortgagee. Guarantors who pay a bank debt can acquire subrogation rights over the security, and Cooper Grace Ward has written about cases where those rights outranked a subsequent registered mortgagee. A caveat or unregistered interest can raise similar disputes. It’s another reason to check the title before you lend or borrow behind a bank.

What can the borrower do while there’s still time?

The window runs from the default notice to the exchange of contracts. After that, a sale is committed. Before it, the options are broader:

1. Get the numbers in writing. Ask the first lender for a current payout figure, the arrears and its enforcement costs.
2. Talk to the second lender immediately. It has the strongest interest in a better outcome than a forced sale.
3. Test a refinance. A private first mortgage can pay out the bank and the second mortgage together, leaving a single loan with a defined exit. It needs enough equity, and no formal valuation is required for assessment, which removes one common delay.
4. Sell it yourself. An owner’s private sale at market price usually beats a mortgagee’s sale, and the bank can generally agree to it if it is repaid at settlement. Our page on stopping a mortgagee sale walks through the steps.
5. Check the lender’s conduct. AFCA’s published approach to mortgagee sales is a useful guide to what a reasonable process looks like.

Already facing a default notice? Check your options with a specialist while there is still time to refinance both loans in one settlement.

If you’re the borrower and the second mortgage is with a different lender from the first, resist the urge to let the two lenders work it out. They are not on the same side.

What if my second mortgage is actually a caveat?

A caveat isn’t a registered mortgage, and it can leave the holder in a weaker position in a sale. Its ranking depends on lodgement and the nature of the interest, and a mortgagee’s sale can sweep it away. If your lender is only on title by caveat, convert it to a registered second mortgage as soon as the circumstances allow, which will usually need your bank’s consent. See first mortgagee consent for how that works.

Does a first mortgagee sale affect the business, not just the property?

Yes. If the property is where the business trades or the security for working capital, a sale can strip the business of premises and lender goodwill at once. Directors who gave personal guarantees can face claims on the shortfall. Our guide to paying out a second mortgage early shows how a payout figure is built, which is useful when you’re negotiating against the clock.

Behind on the first loan? Find out where you stand

If a first mortgagee is moving towards a sale, the best result is usually one where the property never goes to market in a hurry. We lend against property for business purposes, including refinancing a bank first mortgage and clearing a second mortgage in the same settlement, with open terms and no formal valuation required.

Enquiring takes about 60 seconds and asking won’t touch your credit file. We lend directly, so your details don’t go out to a pile of lenders and your phone won’t light up. A real person reads your enquiry and calls you about your own situation. Please fill the form in accurately, including what’s owing on each mortgage and any notices you’ve received, so we can point you to the right option the first time.

See if you qualify →